1. Is encryption always end to end
End-to-end encryption means a message is decrypted only on the devices of the people talking. It matters that it is on by default for all chats, groups, files and calls, not just in a separate “secret” mode.
2. What the server sees
Even if the text is encrypted, the server may know who is writing to whom, when and how often. This metadata sometimes reveals as much as the content. Look for a messenger whose server does not know who sent a message.
3. What happens if the server is seized
Ask directly: if the server is seized or hacked, what does the attacker get? The right answer is only ciphertext, because there are no keys on the server.
4. Is the messenger ready for quantum computers
Messages recorded today may be targeted for decryption in the future, when powerful quantum computers appear. Secure messengers already use post-quantum key exchange combined with the familiar kind.
5. What happens if a key is copied
A good protocol keeps renewing its keys. Then even a copied key becomes useless within a few messages, and the conversation is private again without anyone having to act.
6. How the other person is verified
To make sure nobody sits between you, the other person needs to be verified. If that means comparing long codes by hand, almost nobody does it. It is better when verification happens on its own and the app warns you about a new unverified device.
7. What strangers can do
Scams and spam come from strangers. A secure messenger limits them: at first only a contact request and a short text, with files and calls only after you agree.
8. How files are handled
Attachments are the most common way to infect a device. Files should be checked before they are opened and never run on their own, and programs and scripts should be blocked.
9. Who tested the protection, and how
Are there automated tests, checks for timing leaks, formal models of the protocol, an independent audit? An honest supplier says what has already been done and what is only planned.
10. Does the supplier talk about limits
No messenger can stop the other person from photographing the screen with another phone, and an infected device can see everything its owner sees. If a supplier promises “absolute protection” and says nothing about limits, that is a reason to be wary.
Three more questions for a company
- Can the server be installed on your own premises?
- Can an administrator manage access without holding the keys to the content?
- What happens to work conversations when an employee leaves?
How CUBRA answers these questions
CUBRA encrypts everything from person to person with two independent layers and post-quantum keys, the server does not know the sender, keys heal themselves, the other person is verified automatically, strangers are limited and files are checked before they are opened. We describe the limits openly on the “Security and transparency” page.